Shame and Oreos

Our actions and behaviors are strongly influenced by our internal state of mind and sense of self. I think we’d all agree that we make better decisions when we’re feeling calm and centered, compared to when we’re in an agitated or distressed state. Something perhaps more difficult to address is the role that shame plays in our behavior, as it can be pervasive and, left unchecked, may become a backdrop to nearly all of our decisions.
Shame can manifest as the belief that we are flawed at our core; if people were to see the deepest part of ourselves, we would be unlovable. It’s not hard to see how having a persistent sense of shame could lead to perpetual internal conflict—whenever a part of us tries to succeed, the shamed part tells us that we’re not worthy of that success. This could affect any part of our lives that might potentially bring us happiness: asking out someone we have a crush on, advocating for ourselves for a promotion at work, or attempting a difficult athletic event like a marathon. When we look inside ourselves for the confidence and stability of an inner cheerleader, we are instead met by a voice that tells us that we’re not ever going to be good enough or that we’re unworthy of that success.
So, if we’re experiencing this sort of shame, what can we do?
My friend is a pre-school teacher. One of her students is a little boy who comes to school every day with a sandwich and a pack of Oreos. On the first day of class, my friend saw him hunched over in a corner of the room scarfing down Oreos as fast as he could. He was clearly trying to hide the fact he was eating them, because he hadn’t yet eaten his sandwich. When she asked him what he was doing, he broke down in tears because he believed that he was doing something wrong. In that moment, my friend understood that he must be carrying some hidden or unknown pain, possibly from being shamed or punished for his eating habits in the past. My friend hugged him and told him that she wasn’t mad at him and that it would be totally fine if he finished his Oreos, reassuring him that everything was okay. Over the next few days, the little boy started eating his sandwich first and would proudly show my friend the teacher that he’d finished his sandwich, before diving into his beloved Oreos.
If my friend reacted in anger at the boy (in a sense, punishing him), maybe he would have started eating the sandwich first anyways. But he wouldn’t have been empowered to make the decision himself; rather he’d have been forced into it through threat of emotional pain or shame. By practicing some self-compassion, we might be able to motivate ourselves to make the right decision rather than shaming ourselves to keep us from making the wrong one. As with the teacher and the boy, the caring and wise part of us connects with and guides the part holding the shame, and the two work together to develop behavior that ultimately benefits the whole system.
The antidote for shame is probably not punishment or self-recrimination, as then we’d just be fighting our internal pain by inflicting more pain, likely creating a vicious cycle. Rather, we can try to sit with and reassure our distressed, shamed parts, like my teacher friend did with her student. Some seemingly intractable conflicts, whether they are taking place within us or in the outside world, can be reassessed and better handled by changing our approach to one that more deeply considers our pain and shows compassion for our shared humanity, with all its merits and foibles.
If you’re interested in hearing more on this topic, please join us for episode sixteen of the Facing the Moment podcast, Transforming Grueling Conflicts, where Toufic Hakim, PhD, and Chady Rahme, PhD, discuss the causes of and responses towards conflict through the lens of their personal experience growing up in the midst of civil war.
